We explored the effectiveness of asthma rescue medication on lung function through a thorough analysis of data collected during the Fresno Asthmatic Children's Environment Study from 2000 to 2002. Our research utilized a method known as inverse probability of treatment weighting (IPTW) to evaluate treatment effects in an observational study context. This approach helps us account for various confounding factors that might influence the outcomes we observe.
In our findings, traditional regression methods suggested that there was no significant association between medication use and improved lung function. This might seem surprising, as one would intuitively expect that asthma medication helps improve breathing. However, we believed that this outcome was likely influenced by confounders, such as asthma symptoms and severity, which can muddle the clear effects of medication.
When we applied our marginal structural model approach, we discovered a causal link between medication use and a 7% improvement in pulmonary function. This suggests that when we accounted for other influences adequately, asthma rescue medication does indeed have a positive impact, contrary to previous findings.
We hope that our discussion on the importance of proper model selection and fitting procedures encourages more researchers to consider these aspects seriously when evaluating treatment effects. By understanding the subtleties of our methodologies, we can better justify our conclusions in the realm of asthma treatment.
Read More
9
Zinc salicylate with MSM aids asthma
Zinc salicylate reduces airway smooth muscle cells remodelling by blocking mTOR and activating p21.
We investigated how a combination of zinc salicylate and methylsulfonylmethane (MSM) affects airway smooth muscle cells in people with asthma. Our approach involved treating these cells with different substances, including zinc chloride and sodium salicylate, to see how they influenced cell growth and tissue remodeling related to asthma.
During our study, we observed that both zinc salicylate and the combination with MSM significantly reduced the proliferation of these cells in response to growth factors, while the other compounds showed varying results. Additionally, this reduction in cell growth was associated with increased levels of a key regulator called p21, which plays a role in inhibiting the cell cycle.
Notably, zinc salicylate, especially in combination with MSM, also appeared to limit the deposition of harmful extracellular matrix components like fibronectin and collagen type-I, which are crucial in tissue remodeling. Our findings suggest that this combination may help manage asthma by targeting important signaling pathways involved in cell behavior and tissue structure.
Overall, we believe that the inclusion of zinc salicylate with MSM represents a promising area for further research in asthma management, especially considering its potential to reduce harmful remodeling of the airways.
Read More
4
Exploring asthma treatment analysis methods
Using marginal structural models to analyze randomized clinical trials with non-adherence and lost to follow up.
We set out to better understand how marginal structural models (MSMs) could shed light on the effectiveness of asthma treatments in the context of non-adherence and participants dropping out of the studies. By incorporating these models, we could gain insights into whether the conventional Intention to Treat (ITT) analyses, which may be skewed by these factors, still hold up.
In this study, we analyzed data involving 488 participants, observing that 36% did not stick to their assigned treatment and 17% were lost to follow-up. Through our analysis, we found that the relative risks for different asthma treatments, such as theophylline and montelukast, were very similar when comparing results from both the ITT analysis and the MSM approach.
These findings suggest that adherence issues and follow-up losses might not significantly undermine ITT analyses when it comes to evaluating asthma medications. However, we also noted a lack of existing guidelines on when to rely more on MSMs than ITT analyses. This means that performing MSMs as a supplemental check to ITT analyses may be beneficial for researchers looking at clinical trials with these common challenges.
Read More
Most Useful Reviews
9
Reduced asthma reliance
Its anti-inflammatory properties helped me with asthma; I realised I wasn’t using my asthma spray anymore. I also had ongoing neck pain, which has settled down. MSM comes highly recommended by Jason Hommel, who does "The Copper Revolution: Healing with Minerals".
Read More
7.5
Decreased asthma severity
10 people found this helpful
An irreplaceable thing for people with allergies. Surprisingly, an allergy to mould, cats, and dust in our family has decreased and, in some cases, completely gone. I hope to get rid of asthma.
Read More
6
Relieved asthma symptoms
6 people found this helpful
MSM is essentially sulphur, vital for synthesising collagen and keratin, crucial for skin, hair, and nails. Without sulphur, detoxification of the body does not occur. Sulphur can relieve severe symptoms of asthma and allergies, so don't hesitate to take MSM as a dietary source of sulphur.
We investigated how a combination of zinc salicylate and methylsulfonylmethane (MSM) affects airway smooth muscle cells in people with asthma. Our approach involved treating these cells with different substances, including zinc chloride and sodium salicylate, to see how they influenced cell growth and tissue remodeling related to asthma.
During our study, we observed that both zinc salicylate and the combination with MSM significantly reduced the proliferation of these cells in response to growth factors, while the other compounds showed varying results. Additionally, this reduction in cell growth was associated with increased levels of a key regulator called p21, which plays a role in inhibiting the cell cycle.
Notably, zinc salicylate, especially in combination with MSM, also appeared to limit the deposition of harmful extracellular matrix components like fibronectin and collagen type-I, which are crucial in tissue remodeling. Our findings suggest that this combination may help manage asthma by targeting important signaling pathways involved in cell behavior and tissue structure.
Overall, we believe that the inclusion of zinc salicylate with MSM represents a promising area for further research in asthma management, especially considering its potential to reduce harmful remodeling of the airways.
Read More
8
Asthma medication boosts lung function
An application of model-fitting procedures for marginal structural models.
We explored the effectiveness of asthma rescue medication on lung function through a thorough analysis of data collected during the Fresno Asthmatic Children's Environment Study from 2000 to 2002. Our research utilized a method known as inverse probability of treatment weighting (IPTW) to evaluate treatment effects in an observational study context. This approach helps us account for various confounding factors that might influence the outcomes we observe.
In our findings, traditional regression methods suggested that there was no significant association between medication use and improved lung function. This might seem surprising, as one would intuitively expect that asthma medication helps improve breathing. However, we believed that this outcome was likely influenced by confounders, such as asthma symptoms and severity, which can muddle the clear effects of medication.
When we applied our marginal structural model approach, we discovered a causal link between medication use and a 7% improvement in pulmonary function. This suggests that when we accounted for other influences adequately, asthma rescue medication does indeed have a positive impact, contrary to previous findings.
We hope that our discussion on the importance of proper model selection and fitting procedures encourages more researchers to consider these aspects seriously when evaluating treatment effects. By understanding the subtleties of our methodologies, we can better justify our conclusions in the realm of asthma treatment.
Read More
4
Exploring asthma treatment analysis methods
Using marginal structural models to analyze randomized clinical trials with non-adherence and lost to follow up.
We set out to better understand how marginal structural models (MSMs) could shed light on the effectiveness of asthma treatments in the context of non-adherence and participants dropping out of the studies. By incorporating these models, we could gain insights into whether the conventional Intention to Treat (ITT) analyses, which may be skewed by these factors, still hold up.
In this study, we analyzed data involving 488 participants, observing that 36% did not stick to their assigned treatment and 17% were lost to follow-up. Through our analysis, we found that the relative risks for different asthma treatments, such as theophylline and montelukast, were very similar when comparing results from both the ITT analysis and the MSM approach.
These findings suggest that adherence issues and follow-up losses might not significantly undermine ITT analyses when it comes to evaluating asthma medications. However, we also noted a lack of existing guidelines on when to rely more on MSMs than ITT analyses. This means that performing MSMs as a supplemental check to ITT analyses may be beneficial for researchers looking at clinical trials with these common challenges.
Read More
User Reviews
USERS' SCORE
Good
Based on 4 Reviews
8.1
All Reviews
Positive Reviews
Negative Reviews
9
Reduced asthma reliance
Its anti-inflammatory properties helped me with asthma; I realised I wasn’t using my asthma spray anymore. I also had ongoing neck pain, which has settled down. MSM comes highly recommended by Jason Hommel, who does "The Copper Revolution: Healing with Minerals".
Read More
7.5
Decreased asthma severity
10 people found this helpful
An irreplaceable thing for people with allergies. Surprisingly, an allergy to mould, cats, and dust in our family has decreased and, in some cases, completely gone. I hope to get rid of asthma.
Read More
6
Relieved asthma symptoms
6 people found this helpful
MSM is essentially sulphur, vital for synthesising collagen and keratin, crucial for skin, hair, and nails. Without sulphur, detoxification of the body does not occur. Sulphur can relieve severe symptoms of asthma and allergies, so don't hesitate to take MSM as a dietary source of sulphur.
Read More
6
Supports asthma relief
1 people found this helpful
MSM is sulphur, necessary for collagen and keratin synthesis for the skin, hair, and nails. It plays a role in body detoxification and can relieve severe symptoms of asthma and allergies. Sulphur supports joint health, reduces inflammation, and normalises haemoglobin levels—especially effective for treating joint inflammation.
Read More
Frequently Asked Questions
Asthma is a chronic condition that affects the airways in the lungs, resulting in symptoms like wheezing, coughing, shortness of breath, and chest tightness. The airways can become inflamed and narrowed, making it difficult to breathe, especially during physical activities or during an asthma attack triggered by allergens, irritants, or stress. While asthma can affect individuals of any age, it often begins in childhood, and its severity can vary from mild to life-threatening.
Management of asthma involves avoiding known triggers and using medications such as inhalers that contain bronchodilators and corticosteroids to reduce inflammation and improve airflow. Regular check-ups with a healthcare provider can help individuals manage their condition effectively and develop an asthma action plan tailored to their specific needs. With proper management, many individuals with asthma lead active, healthy lives.
Methylsulfonylmethane (MSM) is a naturally occurring sulfur compound that is often used as a dietary supplement. It is found in various fruits, vegetables, grains, and animal products, but its concentration in these foods is relatively low. MSM gained popularity for its potential health benefits, particularly in the realms of joint health, anti-inflammatory effects, and skin care. Many users report improvements in symptoms related to osteoarthritis and joint pain when using MSM supplements.
The mechanism behind MSM's effects is believed to be related to its ability to support the body's production of collagen, which is essential for maintaining healthy cartilage and connective tissues. Additionally, MSM is thought to have antioxidant properties that might help combat oxidative stress, further promoting joint and overall health. However, while many anecdotal reports support these claims, scientific research on the efficacy of MSM is still ongoing. As with any supplement, it's crucial to consult with a healthcare professional before incorporating MSM into your regimen, especially if you have underlying health conditions or are taking other medications.
Based on user reviews, the time it takes to see results from taking this supplement for asthma can vary. Some users note significant improvements in their symptoms fairly quickly, with one review mentioning a reduction in reliance on asthma spray after starting the supplement, indicating noticeable effects Read Review. However, specific timelines for results are not consistently detailed across the reviews.
Another review highlights a broader benefit related to allergies, with symptoms, including asthma, showing improvement over time without giving a definitive timeframe Read Review. Overall, it appears that users may begin to experience some relief relatively soon, but individual results will vary based on personal health conditions and consistency of use. Always consult with a healthcare professional to tailor the best approach to your health needs.
The combination of zinc salicylate with methylsulfonylmethane (MSM) shows promising potential for asthma management, according to recent scientific findings. A study indicated that this combination significantly reduced the proliferation of airway smooth muscle cells in response to growth factors, which is an important factor in asthma pathology. The results highlighted the increased levels of p21, a key regulator that inhibits the cell cycle, alongside reduced deposition of harmful extracellular matrix components associated with airway remodeling. These effects suggest that zinc salicylate combined with MSM could help mitigate harmful changes in airway structure, marking it as a promising avenue for further research in asthma treatment [2].
However, it's essential to note that while this combination shows potential, there is still a lack of comprehensive guidelines on its application in clinical settings. Further research is necessary to establish clearer therapeutic protocols and validate the clinical effectiveness of zinc salicylate and MSM for asthma patients. Overall, while preliminary findings are encouraging, the broader implications for asthma treatment call for additional studies to fully understand their efficacy and safety [1].
Users have reported various improvements in their symptoms after incorporating this supplement into their routines. Notably, one user remarked on a significant reduction in their asthma symptoms, stating they no longer needed to use their asthma spray regularly after starting the supplement. This speaks to the potential anti-inflammatory properties that may offer relief for asthma sufferers Read Review. Additionally, another user noted a decrease in family allergies to mold, cats, and dust, with some symptoms reportedly disappearing entirely, which aligns with the general sentiment that the supplement can have a positive impact on allergy-related conditions alongside asthma Read Review.
Furthermore, the essence of the supplement, as a sulfur source, has been highlighted as vital for various bodily functions, including detoxification and the synthesis of collagen and keratin, suggesting that its benefits extend beyond just asthma relief Read Review. Reviewers have also pointed out that it helps reduce inflammation and supports joint health, making it potentially beneficial for those dealing with joint-related issues as well Read Review. However, individual results can vary based on health conditions and consistent use, so consulting a healthcare professional is advisable for personalized guidance.
Users have reported a variety of positive experiences when combining this supplement with other supplements for managing asthma. Several reviews highlight the anti-inflammatory properties of MSM, which is noted to help reduce asthma symptoms significantly. One user mentioned that after starting the supplement, they found themselves no longer needing to rely on their asthma spray, indicating a substantial improvement in their condition Read Review. Additionally, another user observed a decrease in allergy-related symptoms for their family members, including issues with mold and dust, which complements the supplement's reported benefits for asthma Read Review.
Moreover, the supplement has been recognized for its role as a dietary source of sulfur, which is essential for detoxification and the synthesis of collagen and keratin, further enhancing its utility in comprehensive health routines. Users emphasize that sulfur's capability to alleviate severe asthma and allergy symptoms makes it a valuable addition to their supplement stacks Read Review. When combined with other supplements that may also target inflammation or support immune health, MSM appears to synergistically enhance overall wellness and respiratory health, making it a noteworthy option for those managing asthma and related allergies Read Review.
Based on user reviews, MSM has been reported to offer relief for asthma symptoms, yet specific dosage recommendations appear to be absent from the feedback. Users have shared that incorporating MSM into their routines has led to a decrease in their reliance on asthma sprays, suggesting a potential improvement in their condition. For instance, one review noted that following MSM treatment, the individual realized they “weren’t using [their] asthma spray anymore” Read Review. Moreover, another user highlighted the use of MSM in alleviating allergy symptoms, which may indirectly benefit asthma sufferers Read Review.
While users emphasize the importance of sulfur derived from MSM for detoxification and symptom relief, explicit dosage information isn’t provided in the reviews. Several testimonials confirm that MSM is effective in reducing severe asthma and allergy symptoms, suggesting its essential role in respiratory health Read Review. This points to the significance of considering individual responses and possibly consulting with a healthcare provider for personalized dosage recommendations.
9
Reduced asthma reliance
Its anti-inflammatory properties helped me with asthma; I realised I wasn’t using my asthma spray anymore. I also had ongoing neck pain, which has settled down. MSM comes highly recommended by Jason Hommel, who does "The Copper Revolution: Healing with Minerals".
7.5
Decreased asthma severity
10 people found this helpful
An irreplaceable thing for people with allergies. Surprisingly, an allergy to mould, cats, and dust in our family has decreased and, in some cases, completely gone. I hope to get rid of asthma.
6
Relieved asthma symptoms
6 people found this helpful
MSM is essentially sulphur, vital for synthesising collagen and keratin, crucial for skin, hair, and nails. Without sulphur, detoxification of the body does not occur. Sulphur can relieve severe symptoms of asthma and allergies, so don't hesitate to take MSM as a dietary source of sulphur.
6
Supports asthma relief
1 people found this helpful
MSM is sulphur, necessary for collagen and keratin synthesis for the skin, hair, and nails. It plays a role in body detoxification and can relieve severe symptoms of asthma and allergies. Sulphur supports joint health, reduces inflammation, and normalises haemoglobin levels—especially effective for treating joint inflammation.
9
Zinc salicylate with MSM aids asthma
Zinc salicylate reduces airway smooth muscle cells remodelling by blocking mTOR and activating p21.
We investigated how a combination of zinc salicylate and methylsulfonylmethane (MSM) affects airway smooth muscle cells in people with asthma. Our approach involved treating these cells with different substances, including zinc chloride and sodium salicylate, to see how they influenced cell growth and tissue remodeling related to asthma.
During our study, we observed that both zinc salicylate and the combination with MSM significantly reduced the proliferation of these cells in response to growth factors, while the other compounds showed varying results. Additionally, this reduction in cell growth was associated with increased levels of a key regulator called p21, which plays a role in inhibiting the cell cycle.
Notably, zinc salicylate, especially in combination with MSM, also appeared to limit the deposition of harmful extracellular matrix components like fibronectin and collagen type-I, which are crucial in tissue remodeling. Our findings suggest that this combination may help manage asthma by targeting important signaling pathways involved in cell behavior and tissue structure.
Overall, we believe that the inclusion of zinc salicylate with MSM represents a promising area for further research in asthma management, especially considering its potential to reduce harmful remodeling of the airways.
4
Exploring asthma treatment analysis methods
Using marginal structural models to analyze randomized clinical trials with non-adherence and lost to follow up.
We set out to better understand how marginal structural models (MSMs) could shed light on the effectiveness of asthma treatments in the context of non-adherence and participants dropping out of the studies. By incorporating these models, we could gain insights into whether the conventional Intention to Treat (ITT) analyses, which may be skewed by these factors, still hold up.
In this study, we analyzed data involving 488 participants, observing that 36% did not stick to their assigned treatment and 17% were lost to follow-up. Through our analysis, we found that the relative risks for different asthma treatments, such as theophylline and montelukast, were very similar when comparing results from both the ITT analysis and the MSM approach.
These findings suggest that adherence issues and follow-up losses might not significantly undermine ITT analyses when it comes to evaluating asthma medications. However, we also noted a lack of existing guidelines on when to rely more on MSMs than ITT analyses. This means that performing MSMs as a supplemental check to ITT analyses may be beneficial for researchers looking at clinical trials with these common challenges.
References
Lancet EA, Borrell LN, Holbrook J, Morabia A. Using marginal structural models to analyze randomized clinical trials with non-adherence and lost to follow up. Ann Epidemiol. 2021;63:22. doi:10.1016/j.annepidem.2021.07.001
Fang L, Roth M, S'ng CT, Tamm M, Han B, et al. Zinc salicylate reduces airway smooth muscle cells remodelling by blocking mTOR and activating p21. J Nutr Biochem. 2021;89:108563. doi:10.1016/j.jnutbio.2020.108563
Mortimer KM, Neugebauer R, van der Laan M, Tager IB. An application of model-fitting procedures for marginal structural models. Am J Epidemiol. 2005;162:382.